Green Party backs calls for ‘fatally flawed’ Bill to be rejected

The Green Party is backing the calls for the ‘fatally flawed’ Oranga Tamariki (Youth Justice Demerit Points) Amendment Bill to be rejected.

“We already know, based on evidence, that the kind of approach this Bill represents will only cause more harm to vulnerable children and young people, will lead to reoffending and will not keep our communities safe,” Green Party spokesperson for Justice Golriz Ghahraman says.

The Bill, currently in front of the Social Services and Community Select Committee, has been called ‘fatally flawed’ by Children’s Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft, and rejection calls have been heard from a number of submitters including Professor Ian Lambie, The Māori Law Society, UNICEF Aotearoa New Zealand and VOYCE Whakarongo Mai.

“Continuing to push for this kind of outdated, punitive approach is dishonest and does nothing but make opportunistic politicians look ‘tough on crime’.

“It is overly simplistic and fails to recognise the complex situations of young people’s lives, through no fault of their own, and will penalise their trauma.

“Young Māori and their whānau, who are already significantly more targeted by the justice system and have more contact with the Police due to racial profiling, will be disproportionately impacted by this Bill.

“We know that children within our criminal justice system are also disproportionately those who have suffered trauma, young people with disabilities, and those who have experienced state care.

“We need to focus our attention on earlier intervention and wrap-around support for young people and their whānau. We need to focus on the drivers of inequity, inaccessible education, the persistent housing crisis, and providing young people with their basic human rights.

“This was a NZ First Member’s Bill that got picked up by National, and the overwhelming majority of New Zealanders voted against those parties and their misguided approach to justice issues.

“The evidence is clear, and this Bill should be rejected outright.”

ENDS

Latest Justice Announcements

Story

Labelling kids serious offenders sets rangatahi up to fail

The Government’s archaic ‘tough on crime’ approach is weak on evidence and will do little to nothing to keep our communities safe.
Read More

Story

Three strikes has failed before and will fail again

Resurrecting the archaic three-strikes legislation is an unwelcome return to a failed American-style approach to justice.
Read More

Story

Hate speech law fails women, Rainbow and disabled people

The Green Party today welcomed the first reading in Parliament of legislation to protect religious groups from hate speech, but remain concerned th...
Read More

Story

Hate speech change welcome, but still leaves communities at risk

The Green Party welcomes hate speech reform to protect religious groups, but is concerned that the exclusion of women, rainbow, and disability comm...
Read More

Story

Young people deserve better

The National Party’s plan to put children into military boot camps is so flawed it is dangerous.
Read More

Story

Minister Hipkins way off the mark on unlawful Police action

The Green Party is calling on Minister Hipkins to address the underlying causes of crime, rather than to allow for abusive, American-style policing...
Read More