Report into diplomat debacle shows Ministers’ failures

The report into the treatment of a diplomat found guilty of indecent assault highlights a failure of Government Ministers to show political leadership over sexual violence, the Green Party said today.

The report into the treatment of a diplomat found guilty of indecent assault highlights a failure of Government Ministers to show political leadership over sexual violence, the Green Party said today.

After months of refusing to release the report by former Treasury Secretary John Whitehead, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) has finally made public the findings. The report only looks at the actions of MFAT officials and how they led to Malaysian diplomat Muhammad Rizalman bin Ismail being allowed to leave New Zealand before being tried for indecently assaulting Wellington woman Tania Billingsley. The report doesn’t cover the actions of Ministers.

Following the assault, Malaysian officials invoked Mr Rizalman’s right to diplomatic immunity and he was allowed to leave the country, after New Zealand officials had indicated they approved of the move.

“This report reinforces the National Government’s poor record on sexual violence,” said Green Party women’s spokesperson Jan Logie.

"From the Prime Minister’s rape comments to this report, National Ministers keep showing how unimportant they consider the issue of sexual violence to be.

“Ministers were told about the attack on Ms Billingsley well before Muhammad Rizalman bin Ismail was allowed to leave the country.

“The Ministers of Foreign Affairs and Police both had an opportunity to show leadership and to ensure that officials treated the attack seriously. Instead they removed themselves from the review.

“The report clearly shows there was no attempt made by the Murry McCully, the Prime Minister or Police Minister Anne Tolley to keep an eye on what was happening with the Rizalman case.

“By excluding themselves from the investigation, they further perpetuated their lack of political leadership on this issue.

“They not only failed Tania, they also failed to provide the leadership that New Zealanders expect from their Ministers.

“I am sorely disappointed at the way this situation has been handled. The right thing to do would be to ensure an inquiry looks into the actions of all the Ministers in this case, not just the staff.

“This Government needs to do more to help victims of sexual violence, starting with demonstrating proper leadership on this issue,” said Ms Logie.

Latest Social Development Announcements

Story

Government clears the way to automate decisions about people's survival

The Green Party is condemning the Government's move to hand decisions on benefits over to automated systems, warning it will leave more people in h...
Read More

Story

National’s public housing reform ‘cuts costs’ at the expense of our most vulnerable

The Green Party is warning that the Government’s changes to public housing will see more public housing tenants evicted and driven deeper into pove...
Read More

Story

Government legalises debts for survivors of sexual violence and abuse in state care

The Government today passed legislation entrenching nearly 40,000 people, including many sexual abuse and abuse in state care survivors in debt.  
Read More

Story

Another blow to young people as unemployment reaches near nine-year high

Unemployment has surged to its highest level in close to nine years, with young people bearing the brunt of the crisis.
Read More

Story

Govt for the rich failing unemployed New Zealanders

Today’s Ministry of Social Development stats, which show record numbers of New Zealanders relying on benefits, are further proof that the Governmen...
Read More

Story

New high in unemployment as Govt punishes the jobless

Latest stats indicating the worst unemployment numbers since the outbreak of the pandemic are further proof that the Government’s policies are forc...
Read More