Reserve Bank’s failings hurting businesses and households

New information released by the Green Party today shows that the Reserve Bank has failed to forecast inflation accurately over the last four years meaning interest rates have been kept higher than necessary, hurting businesses and households.

Analysis by the Parliamentary Library of Reserve Bank inflation forecasting versus the actual inflation rate shows that the Bank has consistently mis-forecast inflation over the last four years, resulting in a higher Official Cash Rate (OCR) than necessary to control inflation. Higher cash rates lead to higher home mortgage rates and borrowing costs for businesses.

“Poor inflation forecasting by the Reserve Bank has meant interest rates have been kept higher over the last four years than they’ve needed to be,” said Green Party Co-leader James Shaw.

“Higher interest rates hurt economic activity as businesses face higher borrowing costs, hurting job creation in the economy. They also raise the cost of mortgages for home owners.

“Higher interest rates also hurt jobs. According to the Reserve Bank’s own numbers, a one percent rise in the OCR reduces economic output by 0.5 - 1 percent and increases unemployment by 0.5 - 1.2 percent.

Last week, Tony Alexander, Chief Economist at the Bank of New Zealand, criticised the Bank’s inflation management saying, ‘The Reserve Bank is well away from doing its job of keeping inflation between 1 percent and 3 percent over the business cycle.’

“Here’s further evidence of a need to revisit the Reserve Bank’s governance structure,” said Mr Shaw.

“Our current structure relies too heavily on the judgement of one person to set interest rates – the Reserve Bank Governor. No other country in the OECD gives full responsibility for the OCR decision to just one person.

“The Treasury has previously recommended a review of our single decision-maker feature; a review the Minister of Finance has refused without reason.

“It’s time for Bill English to reverse his position and review the Bank’s decision-making structures given the impact OCR decisions have directly on our economy.”

Reserve Bank graph comparing actual inflation against forecast:

 

Chart sources: Parliamentary Library, Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Statements (MPS), Statistics NZ CPI

Latest Finance Announcements

Story

Housing plan a start, but much more needed to meet the scale of the crisis

The Government’s housing announcement is a very small start but it doesn’t go far enough to genuinely meet the scale of the crisis.
Read More

Story

Greens announce 4 point plan to stop runaway housing crisis

The Green Party is calling for bold, transformational measures to stop the accelerating housing crisis that is locking New Zealanders out of a stab...
Read More

Story

Tax data exposes gross inequity between the wealthiest and poorest New Zealanders

Government data today shows that the wealthiest New Zealanders aren’t paying their fair share of tax, whilst everyone else chips in, Green Party sp...
Read More

Story

Economic windfall should be funnelled straight back into communities: Green Party

Following an economic forecast that shows Aotearoa strongly rebounding from COVID-19, and Crown accounts looking much healthier than expected, the ...
Read More

Story

Green Party to abstain from tax changes that will worsen house crisis in absence of tax on assets

The Green Party will abstain from a bill that will make slight changes to income tax brackets.
Read More

Story

Green Party welcome Adrian Orr’s full and frank advice on tax

We welcome Adrian Orr signalling that he will provide advice to the Finance Minister on fiscal measures, include tax changes, to cool the housing m...
Read More

Latest Economic Development Announcements

Story

PREFU shows efforts to keep us all healthy, now we need to revenue raise

PREFU has given a good insight into what was required to ensure New Zealanders were largely supported to continue work and remain healthy during CO...
Read More

Progressive Tax Reform

In Aotearoa, there is enough to go around. But the tax system has allowed wealth to accumulate with a small number of us, while most of us have on...
Read More

Sustainable business

In the wake of COVID-19, we must empower small businesses in Aotearoa to flourish, create new jobs, and support their local communities. The Green ...
Read More

Sustainable jobs

A sustainable economy means good working conditions and fair distribution of the benefits of our natural resources. As we respond to the disruption...
Read More

High tech economy

A strong manufacturing and technology sector will create jobs in low-emissions industries and ensure we can sell Aotearoa’s skills to the world. Th...
Read More

Story

Green Party welcomes first Wellbeing Budget

“The Green Party is proud to welcome New Zealand’s first Wellbeing Budget to deliver change for New Zealanders,” Green Party Co-leader James Shaw s...
Read More